while i love the act of bands covering Boingo (one of my fav bands), and I even like Melee, it was ehhhhh... mediocore at best.
the best Boingo cover still has to go to Jessica Burgan's version of Not My Slave http://www.myspace.com/jessicaburgan
(LISTEN its INCREDIBLE)
and after that I'd probably have to say Jack the Original's cover of Heard Somebody Cry was darn good too
(worth a listen)
sadly while the Dead Band's Party tribute had alot of great bands (PWT's, Finch, The Matches, Hellogoodbye) the covers were either to close to the original or uninspired(well the Finch one was, I was so disapointed, they could have rocked that song)