Cool review, Jack. 80%-85% is exactly where I would've pegged it.
"Part II". So good. The chorus actually reminded me of "Let The Flames Begin". I prefer "Still Into You" to "Now" - it fits the quirky style of the record. Anyway, I LOVE this album. The strongest thing about it is how creative it is. I can't really pinpoint who Paramore sound like anymore. It's clear they've drawn inspiration from a diverse list of artists like the Smiths, Justice, Garbage, 90s funk, 80s retro melodic pop, folk, etc… there's just a lot to take in. You'll catch something new every time you hear the record.
My only issues:
"Proof" is a decent song but the chorus seems a bit out of place to me…anyone else?
I loved the ukelele track the first time I heard it, but repeating it throughout the album is…a bit much.
What I've learned from the reactions to this: people feel threatened by the word "pop", being openminded is asking a lot, and that some who listen to it will immediately run to the Farro brothers. But everyone in the band is just doing their thing, and it feels like their least stressful album yet where they don't want to fit into any particular mold. They just let their hair down completely and went loose.
Like I said, I think the chorus is fantastic - but the rest of the song is just SO close to "Let The Flames Begin" that it either makes the original or this song a little irrelevant. There's no way I'd listen to both songs in the same playlist.
Wait, you thought the verses and melodies had a "Let the Flames Begin" sound? I read that wrong. I'd say that about the chorus...
I love them and all the albums, but damn this one is their best. And the interludes are just damn cool in my opinion. And what I love the most about Hayley's lyrics is that we aren't treated to 17 love songs, which is almost a staple in the genre. It's weird cause Proof is one of my favorite, anyway. I agree with the review Jack except for Part II (like everyone duh, what were you thinking ;) ). And I would have rated the vocals higher. And kudos to Jeremy and Taylor. The bass is so cool and Taylor is really a talented guy. So bummed I couldn't go to the concert last night.
Our review system is that we rate all of the elements the same, so that the focus is on the overall score. It doesn't necessarily mean that the reviewer thinks the vocals are an 8.
(from SongMeanings) It's pretty well known by now that Part II is a sequel song to "Let The Flames Begin" and of course, the opening lyrics mirror that of LTFB "What a shame we all became such fragile broken things", this begins with "What a shame, what a shame we all remain such fragile broken things".
That was a song about triumph, standing tall together to fight for what we believe in, and for hope, uniting together to hold onto our freedom ("This is how we'll dance, when they try to take us down"). 'Part II' is a reflection on that. In a situation where everyone else has stopped "dancing", this person is now fighting alone in a broken World.
Very well thought out review. Still haven't listened, will just stream it on Spotify next week when it's released. From the preview clips I heard, "Fast In My Car", "Anklebiters", and "Part II" really hit me.