I would have preferred David A. to win because cook sounds like Daughtry and we already have a Daughtry sry2say.

boring song imo

"Cook actually has to sell a line about "looking for that magic rainbow on the horizon." Seriously, who, in 2008, sits down with a piece of paper and a pen and comes up with "magic rainbow"? And how does that song then go on to win a contest of any kind?"

Funny

he deserved to win. and he loved acceptance. i would rather him that David Archuletta whos like a teeny boppin wimp.

cook was the best contestant idol has seen.

Originally Posted by marysxbuddha

I would have preferred David A. to win because cook sounds like Daughtry and we already have a Daughtry sry2say.

boring song imo

But if we already have a Daughtry, then we already have a Jonas Brothers, so Archuleta shouldn't have won either.

Anyway, I was a fan of Chikezie, Smithson and Castro. One of them should have won.

I was down with Cook

Of all of the talent Idol has seen, I feel that David Cook was a very mediocre singer.

I'm not saying he's a bad singer, he just seems extremely mediocre and generic. Then again, better Cook than Archuleta.

American Idol is fake, sorry to rain on your parade

FIRST of all, idol is clearly rigged, IMO.

second of all the winning idol song is always shit because they have a songwrriting competition for the fans.

David Cook has talent, and he likes Acceptance, so that makes me like him more.
He seems like a genuine guy, so maybe things will work out well for him.

jason castro FTW!!

Originally Posted by Joe DeAndrea

But if we already have a Daughtry, then we already have a Jonas Brothers, so Archuleta shouldn't have won either.

Anyway, I was a fan of Chikezie, Smithson and Castro. One of them should have won.

Daughtry's voice sounds like Cook's. JB sounds nothing like Daughtry. JB is Disney, duh.

Originally Posted by marysxbuddha

Daughtry's voice sounds like Cook's. JB sounds nothing like Daughtry. JB is Disney, duh.

I never said JB sounded like Daughtry. You said Cook shouldn't have won because he sounded like Daughtry, so then that means Archuleta shouldn't have won because he sounds like JB.