Album Review
Hint: Follow a reviewer to be notified when they post reviews.
Alesana - Where Myth Fades to Legend Album Cover
Author's Rating
Vocals 5.5
Musicianship 5
Lyrics 3
Production 8
Creativity 3.5
Lasting Value 3
Reviewer Tilt 4.25
Final Verdict: 46%
Member Ratings
Vocals 6.05
Musicianship 5.32
Lyrics 4.79
Production 6.12
Creativity 4.81
Lasting Value 4.8
Reviewer Tilt 5.45
Average: 53%
Inside AP.net
This review was written by an AP.net staff member.

Alesana - Where Myth Fades to Legend

Reviewed by: Drew Beringer (06/02/08)
AlesanaWhere Myth Fades To Legend
Release Date: June 3, 2008
Record Label: Fearless

I’ve decided that I’m going to create a new genre for bands like Alesana. They are the kind of band that’s a little bit screamo, a little bit pop, a little bit metal, and a little bit of country (just kidding about the last one), so it’s difficult to put them into a genre. Until now. I introduce to you “lolcore,” the perfect home to place a band like Alesana, whose music is fairly generic and cookie-cutter, but at the same time mildly entertaining.

The North Carolina sextet brought in Steve Evetts (Saves The Day, Every Time I Die, Senses Fail) to produce their sophomore album, Where Myth Fades To Legend, the follow-up to their Fearless debut, On Frail Wings of Vanity and Wax. What you’ll find on Myth is more of the same: a triple guitar attack that sounds like two guitars most of the time, mediocre lyrics sung by an above average vocalist backed by whiny screams. Even the chorus of opening track “This Is Usually The Part Where People Scream” acts as a self-prophecy: “Welcome to the show/it’s a story you’ve heard a thousand times/so take a seat/and get lost with me.” Which is exactly what happens. Even though the song is nothing special, it’s incredibly catchy and has a big breakdown towards the end, and I’m a sucker for fun breakdowns. And “Goodbye, Goodnight, For Good” delivers that, as well. With aggressive riffs and clean vocals from Shawn Milke, it’s another head-banger.

When I listen to Milke’s vocals, a part of me hears Claudio Sanchez, and the sung vocals are not bad at all throughout the album. It’s the screaming that brings down the work, as it could use some serious improvement. “Seduction” is an all right track that could do without most of the screaming, while “Red And Dying Evening” is dominated by screaming and double-bass drum kicks from Jeremy Bryan, and it actually works for the most part.

“Sweetheart, You Are Sadly Mistaken” is a favorite of mine, as it starts out with some delicate guitar plucking and kicks into a huge riff. Mike sings about his bloodlust for a girl, and other than a few cringe-inducing lines, the lyrics aren’t that bad. “As You Wish” is horrible, as Alesana should stay away from piano ballads. Closing track “Obsession Is Such An Ugly Word” ends the album in decent fashion, with charging riffs from Milke, Adam Ferguson, and Patrick Thompson and bombastic drum kicks, as the album ends raucously with a lot of screaming, guitars, and noise.

Alesana’s Where Myth Fades To Legend is definitely one of the more generic albums you'll hear in 2008. Evetts did a good job producing this album, and there are a few bright spots throughout, such as vocalist Shawn Milke. Of course they are a plethora of flaws, such as some songs sounding the same, poor lyrics, generic screaming, etcetera, etc. There are still a lot of improvements the band needs to make on their next album, until then Alesana will continue to be more Myth than Legend.

Additional InformationTrack Listing:
1. This Is Usually The Part Where People Scream
2. Goodbye, Goodnight, For Good
3. Seduction
4. A Most Profound Quiet
5. Red And Dying Evening
6. Better Luck Next Time, Prince Charming
7. The Uninvited Thirteenth
8. Sweetheart, You Are Sadly Mistaken
9. And They Call This Tragedy
10. All Night Dance Parties In The Underground Palace
11. Endings Without Stories
12. As You Wish
13. Obsession Is Such An Ugly Word
Produced by: Steve Evetts

Alesana are:
Shawn Mike – vocals/guitar/piano
Dennis Lee – lead vocals
Patrick Thompson – guitar
Jeremy Bryan – drums
Adam Ferguson – guitar/vocals
Shane Crump – bass/vocals

Buy it now at

Official Website; Official Myspace; Official AP.net Profile

Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 121
10:28 PM on 06/02/08
Registered User
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
I thought the album sucked except for the songs they redid on their old ep (endings without stories, and they call this tragedy, red and dying evening). If you havent heard it, its alot better than the songs on this album and frail wings

p.s. shawn does the clean vocals, dennis screams and growls
10:29 PM on 06/02/08
User Info.
TheOtherAndrew's Avatar
lolcore, haha. nice.
03:35 AM on 06/03/08
Trollin' Absolutepunk.
User Info.
applesandcyanid's Avatar
Not a bad CD and a very good review.
04:06 AM on 06/03/08
You'd be good for me
User Info.
fadedmemories's Avatar
lol @ lolcore

just a question drew.... where myth fades to legend or from first to last?
08:10 AM on 06/03/08
Be Human
User Info.
symbiote28's Avatar
nobody is reviewing A Skylit Drive's album?
08:50 AM on 06/03/08
Drew Beringer
Senior Editor - @drewberinger - Locked Groove
User Info.
Drew Beringer's Avatar
lol @ lolcore

just a question drew.... where myth fades to legend or from first to last?
FFTL imo
09:03 AM on 06/03/08
sell my old clothes
User Info.
keeplioving's Avatar
if you really want to laugh though, see these guys live
09:09 AM on 06/03/08
mmm tasty
User Info.
LastDeclaration's Avatar
Spot-on review.
09:10 AM on 06/03/08
mmm tasty
User Info.
09:13 AM on 06/03/08
Baskiceball Champion
User Info.
dustyfloors's Avatar
I love "lolcore"

EDIT: The name not always the music...
09:38 AM on 06/03/08
Registered User
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
amazing record
amazing live performance
these guys r amazing
09:42 AM on 06/03/08
Trollin' Absolutepunk.
User Info.
applesandcyanid's Avatar
if you really want to laugh though, see these guys live

This band kills it live, you obviously don't know what you're talking about. One of the best shows of 07 for me was seeing them open for Haste The Day.
09:45 AM on 06/03/08
"Fuck Armageddon, this is Hell"
User Info.
reissgoespunk's Avatar
"lolcore", hahaha!
09:53 AM on 06/03/08
don't you quote me!
User Info.
industrialbelt's Avatar
if you really want to laugh though, see these guys live

More From This Author
Buy the Music

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
AbsolutePunk Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS