Same here, long-time Relient K fan and I can't believe this is the one that made it to #1 on iTunes. I frankly don't even understand. There wasn't a lot of promotion and there was tons of negative word of mouth months before it came out.
I'm completely torn. I've always wanted Relient K to be successful, yet I've never wanted Relient K to sound like this. Oh well, it isn't about me at the end of the day, and if things are going well for them, then kudos.