Funny, I found it in my friend's CD case and threw it out the window while we were driving across the Brooklyn Bridge, sometime in 2004.
At the time, the "for fans of Taking Back Sunday and Thursday!" sticker on the front really annoyed me. That, and the fact that I had been trying to get my friends to listen to anything slightly "heavy" for a long time, and suddenly they were sold on the most watered down, bullshit songs ever (such as "Ohio is for Lovers") after hearing them on MTV repeat.
I'm glad you understand me! ha