Unlike everyone else, I'm actually having a hard time believing this album is ONLY five years old. It just seems like I've known and loved these songs for so long, then to realize it's only been five years feels kind of strange.
Not really a milestone but a fantastic album. Still their best. I'd say it's 59 Sound > Handwritten > American Slang > Sink or Swim. The last two could easily be juggled, because I feel like SoS has held up better but I loved American Slang when it came out. Handrwitten still has to stand the test of time (nothing like throwing a cliche in a Gaslight post). But I think Handwritten has too many great songs to not stick for me.