I agree with this. I have gone from Settle Down and Girls to Robbers and Heart Out. Now I've been on a Pressure kick because it reminds me of a Genesis song. I think with a gun to my head I would pick Robbers and Girls as my favorites.
Totally agree. My favorite changes all the time too but "Robbbers" and "Girls" (as you said) are the ones I keep coming back to if I'm not listening to the record in order. Such a great album.