I think me and you are in the minority. I read a recent interview with them where the singer mentioned they preferred the self-titled over Of All Things. And that this was the second version of the album even, having scrapped the entirety of a first take. While it's totally refreshing to see a band dude cut the bullshit with press for once, that (and the general fan reaction) boggles my fucking mind. The latter blew the former out of the water. Way more vulnerable and successfully experimental. Bummer they're going back to the original sound, but at least we got one "album" of that stuff out of them.
I love that album. I really like s/t, but OATIWSGT is perfect