Illuminaudio didn't do well though. They went from headlining and selling out shows with Craig to opening for washed up bands like Atreyu after Illuminaudio. So not sure what you mean by "never going to get back to being as huge as they should've been after they did that."
They probably will never be as popular during the Bone Palace Ballet days however. A record with Craig after that release would have been huge.
No we're saying the same thing, when I said "did that" it was referring to kicking out Craig, not Illuminaudio (which did alright but not great). If they kept Craig and did the record that I probably would've less liked than Illuminaudio, they would've sold so much. They're never getting to that point again.