Comments: Page 2
Displaying posts 15 - 19 of 19
05:51 AM on 02/21/14
Gregory Robson
Under Rug Swept
User Info.
Gregory Robson's Avatar
This review is really all over the place. I'm not a hardcore Phantogram fan, so don't think I'm taking anything personally here, but it needs to be reiterated: you cannot describe an album as "a miss in every sense of the word" and "painful" then say two-thirds of the tracks are "good", two or three are "can't miss" and give an overall score of 70%. That's not a credible way to go about reviewing something, because you are saying very contradictory things all at once. It's totally fine if you wanted more from the album, but this review comes off as rather ... to borrow your own descriptor, "histrionic".
As I said earlier, I probably was being way too generous by saying seven of the songs were good. I was really just trying to give the band benefit of the doubt. I also said in the comments that really at most, four or five songs are terrific. If there's indecision in the review, it's because I really wanted to like the album. In trying to find winning moments I probably overshot and gave undue credit to at least a couple songs.

As for the rating a 7, anyone who knows my review criteria knows that an album has to be god-awful to get less than a 6 from me. Voices is not god awful. Sarah can sing, and they craft electro-rock well. It's just hopelessly boring. But its not like they are not proficient at what they do. Their back catalog proves that.
05:51 AM on 02/21/14
Gregory Robson
Under Rug Swept
User Info.
Gregory Robson's Avatar
Why was the album a 7 when you said "For all its winning moments (okay, there’s really only a handful), Voices is a laborious, painful and plodding forty-five minutes that absolutely misses in every sense of the word."

So it's painful to listen to but most of it is awesome?
See my above comment. No, it's not awesome. It's awesome in places.
02:49 PM on 02/21/14
i've found a new way
User Info.
midkay's Avatar
You're missing the point. Even your latest re-phrasing, "awesome in places", is a FAR cry from "a miss in every sense of the word".

We're only trying to help, this is clearly inconsistent phrasing, even your attempts to explain yourself are confusing and contradictory, and leaving a lot of readers wondering just what on earth your position on the album really is. The *one* thing you should never come out of a review feeling totally confused about is the author's stance on the media they reviewed.
07:07 PM on 02/25/14
R.I.P. 2 My Youth
User Info.
IPixedYouu's Avatar
I'm a fan of this band. This album's good but "Fall In Love" probably has to be my favorite, though.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate