Even if it were good enough to be considered for a Cin Sun album (and I'm not sure that it is), isn't that the point of having side projects? My main gripe is that almost every song has sounded like a different band wrote it. It honestly feels like there were too many cooks in the kitchen and the band had no direction during the recording process.
I'll try to hold out judgement until hearing the full album - I've enjoyed Chiodos in the past and think that there's some talented musicians in this band. It's just that what's been released thus far has been a little suspect on a number of different levels.