I love how people on here are obsessed with things like "production" and "sound quality" and on and on. Quit acting like you're some recording engineer with a perfect ear. While occasionally I'll notice if something is ridiculously off, most of the time it's either a good song or a bad song. I don't sit and listen and say "oh god if that drum was 1 db louder I could really get into this." So irritating.
Normally I'd agree, but you must admit that this is incredibly poor for today's standard. You can get better quality out of a webcam microphone. My guess is they intentionally went for this sound. Which in my opinion didn't work out in their favor. I bet they'd be fun live though.