Album Review
Trever Keith - Melancholics Anonymous Album Cover

Trever Keith - Melancholics Anonymous

Reviewed by
Trever Keith - Melancholics Anonymous
Record Label: Antagonist Records
Release Date: February 7, 2008 (digital)
"Hello, my name is Trever Keith, and I am a melancholic."

Personally, this quip should have been the introductory track on the longtime Face to Face vocalist's debut solo album, the aptly-titled Melancholics Anonymous. Here, Keith shelves his trademark skate-punk personality for an intimate, quieter version of himself. The record (released on Keith's own Antagonist label) features nearly a dozen tracks, all with their own unique identity. Driven by Keith's honesty, his deeply-personal vocal delivery and a wide array of electronic instruments, the album is truly one of the best solo debuts by a (criminally underrated) frontman. Face to Face was always a bit brighter than most of their peers while coming up on the Warped Tour scene in the 90's, and they were rarely rewarded for it by the public. Such a shame, too, because it is quite evident that Keith is the right guy for the job in his role as singer and songwriter.

As sort of a mesh of Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails) and Ken Andrews (Failure, On, Year of the Rabbit), Keith builds his songs around a drum machine and vocal effects commonly found on alternative albums in the late 1980's. These effects only add to the album, giving every track its own distinct personality and being a worthy demonstration for Keith's restrained vocals. "Pushover" is really the only track here that reminds of Face to Face, and "Half Asleep" is an effective ballad that keeps a steady rhythm and synth-piano in the background. The candid acoustic number "Absolution" allows Keith's vocals to shine as does "Polish," which would be a perfect choice for a single - it's a modern-day Smiths song with Keith's trademark rasp highlighting the song.

As lush and beautiful as it all is, there are some striking similarities to the influences Keith has been inspired by. "Say Goodbye Again" has a jangly guitar rhythm straight from the Cure and "Bleeding Out" breaks wide open in the middle to reveal a Reznor-like angst hidden inside of these tunes ("Incommunicado" does this to much better results). The title track, a moody acoustic number, has hints of Eddie Vedder shining throughout, with Keith's vocals dipping into that deep emotion the Pearl Jam frontman can often do. Honestly, it works for Keith's style - however, it can become distracting at times. Yet the songs are all so intoxicating, it sure is difficult to be hypnotized by the lovely and quite charming change in technique from this SoCal punk icon.

Confidence exudes from each and every cut here, despite the hesitation in the lyrics that Keith has written. It's quite perplexing to hear some of these words come from such a stellar vocal talent who presents an album that sounds as if he sung each note with his head on high. Each track is, in a way, about redemption: "I will pull myself together / I will come up with a plan / It's almost like I never even took a single step / I thought that I was getting somewhere I hadn't even left / I'll be OK, I will be saved," he sings on the title track. "I'm only halfway come undone / A sting that hasn't stung, But waiting..." he painfully reinstates on closing number, "Shine Box," a song that is about holding on to the faith you cherish, one that makes you human.

The sorrow and the pity is definitely there, but for good reason: Keith is grown up, going through all the mature struggles we will one day reach as middle-aged adults and he gives himself a canvas that is used to his full advantage, never stepping over lines he's already drawn for himself. Melancholics Anonymous is heartfelt, painfully intimate and contains songs about belief, acceptance and the will to make one better. Living with yourself is difficult enough, yet somehow, Keith makes this easy to understand and come to grips with. You can never be perfect, and Keith knows that - but he gives more than enough reasons to accept it and carry on in a bigger and better way.

Recommended if You LikeFace to Face (duh), Ken Andrews, a skate-punk version of Nine Inch Nails and late-80's alternative rock
Choice Cuts"Polish," "Half Asleep" and "Shine Box"

Track List1. Cross Your Heart and Hope to Die
2. Sick of Me
3. Incommunicado
4. Polish
5. Absolution
6. Pushover
7. Half Asleep
8. Bleeding Out
9. Say Goodbye Again
10. Melancholics Anonymous
11. Shine Box
BandTrever Keith: vocals, all instruments
Chad Blinman: drums/drum programming

Online VitalsOfficial Site | Official Myspace
PurchaseTrever Keith's Homepage (album is available for download for only $5!)
This review is a user submitted review from smoke4thecaper. You can see all of smoke4thecaper's submitted reviews here.
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 19
02:35 AM on 08/04/08
Obama/Biden 08'
User Info.
Sarbear's Avatar
not going to lie..this is an amazing review. makes me want to listen :)
02:38 AM on 08/04/08
I was born a wise man
User Info.
smoke4thecaper's Avatar
not going to lie..this is an amazing review. makes me want to listen :)
<3 ilu
05:12 AM on 08/04/08
May your music break my ear drums
User Info.
ugman_2000's Avatar
Yeah good review mate I did really enjoy this and I'd recommend it to anyone who is a fan of Face to Face
06:06 AM on 08/04/08
Registered User
User Info.
probe1979's Avatar
This is like... the most underrated man in punk rock music.... FACE TO FACE KICK ASS !!!
06:18 AM on 08/04/08
Registered User
User Info.
246toothpicks's Avatar
Finally something more for the ignorance is bliss fans... this is a great album, go hear it! If those guys decide to record again, hopefully some of this style will spill over into it.
06:39 AM on 08/04/08
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
great review. i find your reviews tend to get me to check out a lot of different artists i may not in other situations and in turn, develop new favorites. Keep on truckin Mr. Fallon
07:08 AM on 08/04/08
Steve Henderson
User Info.
Steve Henderson's Avatar
Haven't listened to this yet, but I must say that is probably the best album title I have seen in a long time.
09:18 AM on 08/04/08
The desperation's gone.
User Info.
lew_1987's Avatar
One of the best reviews I've read on AP. Nice job.


Haven't listened to this yet, but I must say that is probably the best album title I have seen in a long time.

Really agree on this. I wish I had thought of it.
09:41 AM on 08/04/08
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
Great review for an even greater album.
09:58 AM on 08/04/08
Registered User
User Info.
suburbanblues's Avatar
A real review!

Easily the best release of the year.
02:54 PM on 08/04/08
Registered User
User Info.
thefullydown's Avatar
The two songs on his myspace are awesome.

If anyone is into his solo stuff at all check out Ignorance Is Bliss; by far the best facetoface record! It's truly a shame that most facetoface fans had tunnel vision back when it came out. This band could have been even more legendary if they continued on that path; or if their fans allowed them to instead of booing them while touring on it.

02:55 PM on 08/04/08
is a fargin icehole!!!
User Info.
monkeyboyrock's Avatar
I didn't even know this existed, but now I totally have to check it out, for Face to Face are one of the raddest punk rock old schoolers of all time...Trevor Keith is a badass...
05:35 PM on 08/04/08
promesas son sombras
User Info.
EchoPark's Avatar
another great review Chris.

This guy shows Chris Carrabba where to stick it.
08:53 PM on 08/04/08
Registered Member
User Info.
slimfenix182's Avatar
truly a great CD. luckily I found out about this before he did his first solo tour, so I got to see him in Massachusetts at the Middle East. Trever is truly one of the nicest guys I have ever met in the music business. not enough people knew about Face To Face, and probably not enough people will know about this CD. glad to see it get a review on here. it's only 5 bucks through his website too. well worth it. go get it people.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate