AbsolutePunk.net
   Username
Password
 
Album Review
Hint: Follow a reviewer to be notified when they post reviews.
NORTH - What You Were Album Cover
Author's Rating
Vocals 7
Musicianship 7.5
Lyrics 4.25
Production 7.5
Creativity 6
Lasting Value 7.25
Reviewer Tilt 5.5
Final Verdict: 64%
Member Ratings
Vocals 6.75
Musicianship 6.75
Lyrics 6.75
Production 6.75
Creativity 6.75
Lasting Value 6.75
Reviewer Tilt 6.75
Average: 68%
Inside AP.net

NORTH - What You Were

Reviewed by: Scott Irvine (08/12/08)
NORTH - What You Were
Release Date: July 15th, 2008
Record Label: Cavity Records


A part of me thinks NORTH has jumped the shark with this new album; the more accepting part of me, the part of me that gave this, regrettably, much more than it deserved. It’s not a surprise to be honest as I've always been the kind of person who didn't particularly enjoy that one metal kid who is seemingly in every group of friends. Was it so rash to have pegged his ardent following of the genre to be the result of an alcoholic father and an excuse for every bruise come school time? I'm up for reading about the pale horses and the apocalypse if a report calls for it, but do I really have to listen to bad poetry about them being grunted and groaned? My answer has always been 'no'. That's why I was able to withstand and, yes, enjoy NORTH for at least nixing the worst aspect about metal bands and even adding in some spacey atmosphere. With What You Were, though, the band chose to not only add a vocalist to the lineup but also brought HeavyHeavyLowLow's Rob Smith in for some guest vocal work. Awesome?

Hardly. “Ghosts Among Us” tore my spine out, and all I had to do was look at the press sheet that clearly stated I should be expecting something different out of NORTH. What they expressed without words on Ruins has been substituted for unintelligible screams, transcribed in the booklet with such gems as, “I did this all for you/I am death/And yet alone I stay.” Am I listening to metal renditions of Nickelback, or all metal lyricists this terrible and painfully overdramatic?

My legs are open and grateful, however, for how the band still fingers me with electricity, despite all of the compensation for the inevitable tirade of injected vocal clutter. Songs like “Eidolon” remind me why I can’t go a day without listening to music; the opening is absolutely gorgeous (EITS, is that you?) and “leaves me wanting more.” There a few instrumental songs here, but they come far between and are all less than two minutes – essentially “interludes” to make the album seem more novel-esque and much more cohesive than it ought to be considered. As much as bands believe they’re the anti-trend, they still cannot devise a way to bring the album together without using intermissions that were in all probability written the day of recording. The shimmering overlay on most of the album's songs should be expected to be present, the band hasn't completely revamped their style.

A big sigh and move-on for me, another one bites the back of my CD shelves. I’ll pull out NORTH’s previous album every once in a while, but a firm spot on the lowermost shelf tells me Where You Were will be there for some time. I guess I should round this “review” up somehow with a summary on the album, but I’m not going to tug you guys along. Metal is tired, overdone, a slow crawl through a narrowing tunnel of originality. Call me the wrong critic for this assignment, but I’d put money on the rest of the staff saying more or less the same thing. I guess we have sense enough to see a failing rebellion, or fad.




Recommended If You Like:Russian Circles, Rosetta, Tides, Pelican
 
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 24.
01:05 PM on 08/12/08
#2
Praetor
as we melt, let's make no noise.
Offline
User Info.
Praetor's Avatar
Would be much better sans vocals.
03:05 PM on 08/12/08
#3
princesschad
sowing season
Offline
User Info.
princesschad's Avatar
My legs are open and grateful, however, for how the band still fingers me with electricity, despite all of the compensation for the inevitable tirade of injected vocal clutter.

What an amazing line!
12:00 AM on 08/13/08
#4
DogSizedBird
Offline
User Info.
DogSizedBird's Avatar
really, I loved this album. even more so than Siberia and Ruins.
08:40 AM on 08/13/08
#5
Scott Irvine
Your Virtual Pnin
Offline
User Info.
Scott Irvine's Avatar
really, I loved this album. even more so than Siberia and Ruins.

It's all about preference. I don't scoff at you for liking it, it's just a matter of if you like vocals being added or not.
10:14 AM on 08/13/08
#6
youngmountain
http://littlewaves.bandcamp.com/
Offline
User Info.
youngmountain's Avatar
yeh the songs i have heard from this don't really do it for me, it's definetaly the vocals which is strange considering i like isis and cult of luna.
10:24 AM on 08/13/08
#7
youngmountain
http://littlewaves.bandcamp.com/
Offline
User Info.
youngmountain's Avatar
I just listened again on myspace, it's actually not bad, the music is great, it's just the vocals are mixed far too loud and are extemely monotonous which kills the beauty of the music.
10:38 AM on 08/13/08
#8
Gregory Robson
Under Rug Swept
Offline
User Info.
Gregory Robson's Avatar
My legs are open and grateful, however, for how the band still fingers me with electricity, despite all of the compensation for the inevitable tirade of injected vocal clutter.

What an amazing line!

I wholeheartedly disagree. In poor taste and quite sordid.
10:56 AM on 08/13/08
#9
xglassjawx
Sergio Georgini
Offline
User Info.
xglassjawx's Avatar
I love this album.

Bit of an odd review I thought, I don't think it really said what the album really sounds like.

It's all good though, this won't be an album everyone will love!
10:57 AM on 08/13/08
xglassjawx
Sergio Georgini
Offline
User Info.
xglassjawx's Avatar
I just listened again on myspace, it's actually not bad, the music is great, it's just the vocals are mixed far too loud and are extemely monotonous which kills the beauty of the music.

It sounds stupid but I swear on the actual CD they don't sound as ridiculous.
11:50 AM on 08/13/08
TooLateF0rRoses
Offline
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
i want to check this out. after work i will get on it!
01:36 PM on 08/13/08
theDrivingSnow
I wouldn't know.
Online
User Info.
theDrivingSnow's Avatar
This is an amazing release. Don't agree at all.
06:15 PM on 08/13/08
oldwirehands
pherm
Offline
User Info.
oldwirehands's Avatar
The vocals are boring. Some cool riffs here and there. The album is pretty boring overall. Good call Scott.
07:27 PM on 08/13/08
Scott Irvine
Your Virtual Pnin
Offline
User Info.
Scott Irvine's Avatar
Bit of an odd review I thought, I don't think it really said what the album really sounds like.

Uh, did I not make it clear that it sounded like every other metal album I've heard? I thought I drove that point the most. How are you supposed to describe a metal album as an uninitiated listener and a thorough disapprover?
08:58 PM on 08/13/08
meeotch
...all we fight for
Offline
User Info.
meeotch's Avatar
Yea, this doesn't do it for me. Ruins was excellent.
Options
More From This Author
Buy the Music

NEWS, MUSIC & MORE
Search News
Release Dates
Exclusives
Best New Music
Submit News
CONNECT
Forums
Contests
RSS
Mobile Version
Banners, Flyers, Widgets
HIDDEN TREASURES
Free Music
Video News
Sports Forum
AP.net Related News
Recommendations
INFORMATION
FAQ
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
FOLLOW
Twitter | Facebook
PropertyOfZack
PunkNews.org
UnderTheGun
Chorus.fm