i agree that whoa is the weakest on the album (maybe tied with here we go again) but it is the song that made me love this band when i saw them open for the rocket summer 3 years ago. i bet when i'm older and i think back to my high school years i will think of this album. i really don't care what anyone says
I thought both albums were great but I felt a greater attachment to this one more then RIOT! RIOT had a lot of energy but AWKIF had so much emotion to it. Maybe its because I listened to it a lot, that it attached to me.
About the discussion about their weaker song Whoa. It's probably one of their best songs live, you'd had to have heard it(crowd participation is awesome).