I've always felt the same way about Pitchfork - their reviewers are some really talented writers, but they don't listen to music to enjoy it. They listen to everything looking to pick it apart. Not the way I listen to music, or watch television shows or movies or anything else for that matter. Unimpressed with that review.
I can see that. I don't agree with that review what so ever, but I actually really enjoy pitchforks writing for the most part. I feel like when they give an album big praise, it's usually fitting, but they can also be overly harsh. I do like how they don't just throw out contant praise like some writers here.