[maxvsmaradona]

I would like to thank unemployment and New Jersey's Department of Labor. Y'all just got me a Handwritten preorder.

[SoundwaveUproar]

Originally Posted by maxvsmaradona

I would like to thank unemployment and New Jersey's Department of Labor. Y'all just got me a Handwritten preorder.

Just actually laughed out loud to this, i needed it

[Craig Manning]

The 59 Sound>Elsie>American Slang>Sink or Swim

Fight me.

[Polaris]

Originally Posted by narcoleptic953

The 59 Sound>Elsie>American Slang>Sink or Swim

Fight me.

No fights necessary..I agree with this completely.

[RyanFTW]

Yo Ice Cream Is Delicious




Fight Me

[SoundwaveUproar]

i think when i have kids (if)... I'd rather pick my favorite of them than my favorite Fallon release. I just got into sink or swim, and i love it, i love all of it. Every song, from every album.

[mike'smannequin]

Originally Posted by narcoleptic953

The 59 Sound>Elsie>American Slang>Sink or Swim

Fight me.

Yeah this is a no fight needed. Perfect

[mike'smannequin]

Originally Posted by SoundwaveUproar

i think when i have kids (if)... I'd rather pick my favorite of them than my favorite Fallon release. I just got into sink or swim, and i love it, i love all of it. Every song, from every album.

hahaha

[mrnegativezero]

Why would I fight anyone about their opinion?

Personally, I can't get into Elsie as much as everyone else seems to. And I love Sink or Swim a lot more than American Slang. But different opinions, etc. etc.

[ImTheSheriff]

EP > Sink or swim = Elsie > American Slang > The 59 Sound.

[Craig Manning]

I really don't care much for Sink or Swim actually. It's got some good songs, but the production is awful, and its fairly clear that they didn't know who they wanted to be as a band yet. It's always curious to me when someone calls that their best, or expresses a desire for them to return to that sound. Why would you want a band to regress?

[thirtyfourdays]

So here's a question.

I didn't get into Gaslight until "The 59 Sound." I love American Slang, and love Elsie as well. I've gone to see them twice in my lifetime but I've listened to Sink or Swim maybe once or twice, and Senor and the Queen probably the same.

Should I be giving those albums more of a listen?

[CheckeredFloors]

Duh.

[eagles1139]

Originally Posted by thirtyfourdays

So here's a question.

I didn't get into Gaslight until "The 59 Sound." I love American Slang, and love Elsie as well. I've gone to see them twice in my lifetime but I've listened to Sink or Swim maybe once or twice, and Senor and the Queen probably the same.

Should I be giving those albums more of a listen?

Certainly. Especially SatQ...Blue Jeans and White T-Shirts and Wherefore Art Thou, Elvis? are two of their best songs.

[CollectiveConfusion]

I definitely wouldn't rank Senor And The Queen over any of their full lengths. Although I DO love "Blue Jeans And White T-Shirts" like everybody else.