Originally Posted by apm158

if u want to hear every pop punk band to ever play on this Earth rolled into one band, listen to Hit The Lights hahaha

basically.

Open mouth... Insert foot ;)

Originally Posted by gibson_21

Open mouth... Insert foot ;)

Yeah definitely...

Scott got PWN54URD

uh..how did i get pwned again? because they wrote a song about this?

Originally Posted by Scott Weber

uh..how did i get pwned again? because they wrote a song about this?

thats actually pretty damn cool they wrote a song about you. well, if i were you i would think so. i dont think your review was bad at all. You weren't an asshole or anything. You gave a review that if i were to give a review, it would've been along the same lines. scott did not get "pwned" or whatever the stupid fucking computer nerd talk is. i wasnt fond of this band to begin with but now i just dont wanna listen to them at all. How whiney do you have to be to write a song about a reveiw that wasn't even exactly a bad one????

writing a song about a review that was "bashing" them is not whiny**.
they're merely sticking up for themselves as a band and showing that an EP does not define themselves musically. and they did a damn good job.

Originally Posted by ducks eat 4free

writing a song about a review that was "bashing" them is not whiny**.
they're merely sticking up for themselves as a band and showing that an EP does not define themselves musically. and they did a damn good job.

he didnt bash them. he wasn't being an asshole about it. i think everything he said was true. so what if they've sounded like something we've all heard before. first, that doesnt make them suck. And second, you can't say that it doesn't sound like something that has been done before, because it does. i think they are an alright band and i can inderstand how other people really like them, but what if every band wrote a song when a review said they weren't really original?? this has been said about so many bands. they probably knew it would get them important publicity on this site, and with all the kids who will listen to whoever this site promotes, they are probably creaming their pants over it right now.

i think some people are reading into this a bit too much.

i just hope it winds up being the new TBS v BN sort of drama from way back in the day

I love the fact that this review is somewhat mentioned on the opening track to their album.

Originally Posted by NGame

I love the fact that this review is somewhat mentioned on the opening track to their album.

It totally is. Haha. They've talked about it in interviews.

I seriously don't see how you're comparing Colin's voice to Patrick's. Colin can actually sing. =o
( have you ever heard Fall Out Boy live?)


and how was this not a bad review? he's basically telling them that they're not talented.

Scott, how much do you love the fact that you are part of a great song? Cuz I think that's pretty righteous. Rock/Write on.