Any of The Matches LPs (specifically Decomposer). Too $ for Epitaph I guess. Sad.
I have a few great LPs. Too many to list here.
My top 5 (AP genre wise) that I own would be:
Saves The Day - In Reverie
weezer - Pinkerton Deluxe 4xLP
Hellogoodbye - Would It Kill You? (cream) (I also have the coke bottle clear When We First Met '45)
Brand New - Devil & God 2xLP(white)
Phantom Planet - Raise The Dead (clear blue)
How much does In Reverie usually go for now?