Haha no I don't think she got me anything super amazing, it's more that she got me something that made her think of me, and all I can think for her is a gift card - and again I hate gift cards!
I'm thinking I'm gonna go with one of OPI's Sephora gift sets or a Ciate set. They're cute, nice, and she always borrows my nail polish so I think that might be nice. BTWZ she has every MAC brush and piece of makeup. No exaggeration, she has like 60 eyeshadows, it's out of hand haha.
lol I'm the same way as her. I have a makeup dresser and the entire first drawer is only eyeshadow haha. Just with less MAC, unfortunately.
The Sephora for OPI sets are cute. I got one for my sister this year too. But then I had to get her something else also, because I'm dumb and didn't read the description on the one I got, and they were super small and mini. So I got her the Soap & Glory gift set too because it comes with a tote and everybody loves totes. I'm sure she'll like whatever it is. I get impressed when my sisters even get me gifts. I'm sure she'll be flattered that you spent so much time and even created a thread trying to get her something!