The self titled was golden. Had some sequencing issues and I'm not the biggest fan of the song "Money" but it's a great album when you strip away the TAYF lineup expectations. It's definitely my second favorite.
Also, I love New Again. It's my third favorite Taking Back Sunday, and I think (besides the first three songs) is a great record. The closer is in the top 3 songs TBS has ever written.
Yes ! So many jams. "This Is All Now" and "El Paso" are the only songs I still listen to from the last album. I hope we'll eventually get to hear "Why Not A Sexy Pirate" one day (version heard on that Nolan's video).
I hope it's better than the last album but my opinion is biased. The self titled came out right after my longterm girlfriend and i split and it reminds me of that time in my life which just makes me hate it.